keep? return?

floor mat 002
Originally uploaded by dncng_leaf

Problem.

I wanted a new mat to go under my water dish in the kitchen. At the moment I use an old towel.

I ordered both these mats from a catalog intending to return the one I didn't like.

It is sort of an xmas present, not really, but, ya' know? kinda. I'm sure the dogs aren't really going to care either way.

From the catalog image J prefered the red bone but... it doesn't really hold the water dish all that well. Opinions?