shrug pattern?

I'm looking for a shrug pattern - ideally something with sleeves that will stay IN place for dancing and does not need to tie under the bust.

I'm looking at these patterns...

the pictures are crap - so I can't get a good idea of how it is going to turn out

This website has a few different patterns - 

Sleek Shrug - looks easy (but no sleeves at all.) Pluses - it looks like it will stay in place and need minimal fabric.

Cap sleeve  & Bolero jacket patterns -  in theory I should be able to lengthen the sleeve to the length that I want.

I guess I was hoping for something more like this style to about an elbow length for the sleeve.... but I wanted to do it out of fabric not knit/crochet.

suggestions?

cross posted to bellydancegear.